February 4, 2003
Business Judges
Open for Business
A week after Sandra Day O'Connor swore in five newly elected Texas Supreme
Court justices on January 6, high court candidates filed final 2002 campaign
finance reports that provide the last word on who really won the election.
Even with chief justice candidates raising little money, major-party
Supreme Court finalists raised more than $5 million in their pursuit of
five open seats. Every Republican prevailed, with the GOP fielding far
and away the best-funded candidate in every race except that of new Justice
Steven Smith.
Top Donors to 2002 Winners
Employer |
Total to
Winners |
Vinson & Elkins |
$128,105
|
Baker Botts |
$105,025
|
Fulbright & Jaworski |
$73,145
|
Texans for Lawsuit Reform |
$55,910
|
Locke Liddell & Sapp |
$55,145
|
Bass Family |
$53,500
|
Haynes & Boone |
$52,264
|
Beirne Maynard & Parsons |
$52,044
|
Texas Medical Association |
$48,972
|
Bob Perry |
$45,000
|
Hillco PAC |
$40,000
|
Real winners
The election's true winners were the business interests that dug deep
to ensure that their dream team trounced candidates who might be friendlier
to consumers or workers. Of the $3.2 million that the five newly
elected justices raised, 22 percent came from the PACs and employees of
just 11 business interests.
Led by Vinson & Elkins, half of these big donors were corporate
defense firms that have numerous cases before the court. Houston homebuilder
Bob Perry arguably is the new justices' next-largest patron. Apart from
the $45,000 he gave directly, Perry supplied most of the PAC money raised
by HillCo Partners lobby firm; he also is a top Texans for Lawsuit Reform
donor.
White-dog Republicans shape a Supreme race
A newly visible voting bloc of white-dog Republicans shaped the one
race in which an under-funded candidate prevailed. In primary elections,
these voters apparently prefer white, affirmative-action critics named
"Smith" to minority incumbents named "Xavier Rodriguez." When he advanced
to the general election, Steven Smith's party label helped overcome the
huge 20-1 funding superiority of his Democratic opponent. New Justice Smith
prevailed with less than $40,000 in contributions and loans. •
|
January Dollar Docket
Cases heard by the Texas Supreme Court in January and corresponding contributions
to justices from the parties and/or attorneys.
January 8, 2003
|
City of San Benito v. |
$0
|
Southern Union Co |
$96,904
|
|
|
January 15, 2003
|
Forbes, Inc. v. |
$1,025
|
Granada Foods |
$250
|
|
|
Utica Insurance v. |
$36,015
|
American Indemnity |
$8,300
|
|
|
Delta Airlines v. |
$100
|
Black |
$0
|
|
|
January 22, 2003
|
City of Terrell Hills v. |
$0
|
Champion Builders |
$3,700
|
|
|
J&R Valley Oilfield Services v. |
$17,700
|
Garcia |
$0
|
|
|
Kerr McGee Corp. v. |
$310,435
|
Helton |
$0
|
Grand Total for January: |
$474,429
|
|
|
Summary of January 15th
Reports
Place/
Party |
Candidate |
Winner/
Loser |
Total
Raised |
Raised Since
10/27/02 |
Spent Since
10/27/02 |
Cash on
Hand 1/15/03 |
CJ/R |
Phillipsi |
W
|
$9,426
|
$1,710
|
$5,014
|
$3,948
|
CJ/D |
Baker |
L
|
$3,507
|
$0
|
$341
|
$0
|
1/R |
Schneideri |
W
|
$964,820
|
$26,615
|
$84,514
|
$33,628
|
1/D |
Yanez |
L
|
$429,903
|
$27,120
|
$115,002
|
$17,716
|
2/R |
Wainwright |
W
|
$1,084,367
|
$53,133
|
$63,928
|
$75,852
|
2/D |
Parsons |
L
|
$336,971
|
$25,153
|
$9,802
|
$32,417
|
3/R |
Jeffersoni |
W
|
$1,170,046
|
$37,939
|
$126,434
|
$48,536
|
3/D |
Moody |
L
|
$240,300
|
$7,425
|
$36,905
|
$9,381
|
4/D |
Mirabal |
L
|
$826,926
|
$64,933
|
$146,466
|
$49,364
|
4/R |
Smith |
W
|
$28,465*
|
$6,875
|
$8,437
|
$5,445
|
|
TOTALS:
|
|
$5,094,731
|
$250,903
|
$596,843
|
$276,287
|
* Steven Smith also reported receiving a $10,000 Loan
|